Quick Question About Item Quality Article On The Wiki

[trowftd]

Weapons have a quality modifier as follows:

    crude: -1 impact, -10% skill
    rough: -1 impact
    decent (no change - standard 'nonamed type')
    fine: +1 impact
    masterwork: +1 impact, +10% skill

Does this mean you get +2 impact on masterworks or both are +1 compared to decent one.

[PALU]

The values are the net values relative to the baseline (decent), so both rough and crude result in reduced impact, while crude adds a skill penalty on top of that.

Thus, it's your second alternative.